I ride a 2003 Road Star Silverado and my best friend rides a 1999 Road King Classic. We switch bikes quite often. Here is the truth...
1. The Harley is a little bit smaller. You have a tiny bit less room. Not a big deal if you are not tall.
2. Both are excellent bikes and ride and feel very similar. The Harley has probably a smoother drive train, but just a bit.
3. I'll be honest, as pretty as mine is, the Harley is a little bit prettier, especially the engine area. It just is, that's all. Not a big difference or deal.
4. The Yamaha is a little quicker stock than the Harley.
5. Why did I choose my Yamaha. I got a couple year old use with next to no miles for under 8K. The same type of Harley would go for around 15K.
6. The Yamaha is one heck of a lot of bike for the money. If you love the pureness of a classic looking american v-twin, and want to keep it under 10K, buy they Yamaha. If money is not object, then buy which ever one is the sexiest to YOU. The one you keep going into the garage to look at!!!
7. Most important of all...someone earlier said it best when they said that whichever one you choose, you will love the most. Simply put, you will love whichever one you buy and never regret it...unless you have problems with it just like being married. By the way, my friend and I never have problems with either of our bikes
