38 years in the saddle on just about every type of engine there is and, after 14 months on a 99 R, I'm surprised at just how quite the Roadie is. When you consider what's going on between your legs, it's amazing there isn't a lot more racket coming from the engine; pushrods, huge pistons, big gears, big valves..big everything!!!!!!!!!!
Personally I love it. Part of the appeal of 'nostalgia engineering' is the acknowledgement that real engines make noise and sometimes lots of it. A friend of mine was making one-off go-faster bits for some Roadstar drag-racer guy in the US when they first came out and before anyone really got into the aftermarket business. At the time I had a VN1500 Classic and we got into an inevitable comparison discussion. From his perspective the Roadie was and is a superbly engineered, if not over-engineered, motorcycle and he had nothing but praise for it.
Loadmaster, it's a big-arsed engine that will make a racket. In the words of some Harley marketing blurb I read years ago (though I've never actually owned one) in defence of the racket that eminated from pre-evolution shovel engines, he said that the 'mechanical turbulence' that harley engines produced was part of the appeal for owners. Of couse, in that case it could have just been dodgey design, sloppy tolerances and ordinary manufacturing standards.
As for the Roadie and I...long live 'mechanical turbulence'
Reperio