You guys are great! Thanks!
The green plug is connected, didn't touch it. Any other ideas? So you think I need a new part? What's involved in replacing it? Anyone done this before?
The LEDs I connected were a 2 x 24 light red flexible array (mounted under the saddlebags), rear round reflector led conversion, front reflector led conversion. This is in addition to about 5 (step/courtesy) lights that I put on about 2 years ago (this is the wire I tapped into this past weekend) and a Kuryakyn fender eagle with lighted eyes that I put on a few weeks ago. This wire is connected to a switch installed on the left battery side cover, which is then connected to the battery directly, its running all of these lights. No problem with the lights, they all work from the switch and I'm not getting electrocuted when I ride with them on

.
Running separately directly to the battery is a Kuryakyn Infinity Streamliner (lights on a hypercharger cover). The switch is mounted on the back of the frame on the right side behind the rider seat.
I know leds don't draw a lot of power (though the eagle is a little bulb, not led). I hope I'm not overloading the battery.
I have some large halogen silver bullets that I picked up from ebay that I want to mount to my engine guard and I want to add a cobra lightbar as well eventually and a few more running lights (amber button lights on the battery side covers and a 2 x 6 inch (40 light (each) led array to the floorboards). I want to eventually pull the 5 led lights that I mounted previously, and replace with a Kuryakyn Lizard Light Maximus set, connected to the streamliner.
I will probably get a 3 way switch mounted on the handlebars, 1 for the added running lights including the eagle, the reflector conversions and the bag lights and all other LEDs, 1 for the silver bullets and 1 for either the lizard lights or the future lightbar (may connect it directly to the running lights). Turning my bike into a christmas tree (going to call it Star-Lite

). Asking a lot of my little battery, eh? WDYT? Sorry if I gave too much info.
My first concern is getting this fuel gauge problem resolved. WDYT?